Olivia Wilde's neo-noir project exceeds its budget, prompting studio head Matt Remick (Seth Rogen) to cancel the wrap party. When a crucial film reel goes missing, Matt and executive Sal Saperstein (Ike Barinholtz) embark on a frantic search, leading them to suspect lead actor Zac Efron and costume designer Evelyn Dietrichson. Their investigation uncovers unexpected twists, culminating in Matt making a significant personal sacrifice to fund necessary reshoots.