Melissa Jesperson-Moore (Annaleigh Ashford) grapples with the repercussions of publicly sharing her father's identity as the notorious Happy Face Killer. As she navigates media attention, her team questions the innocence of Elijah, a man potentially wrongfully convicted due to Keith Jesperson's (Dennis Quaid) crimes. Meanwhile, Keith faces solitary confinement, intensifying the family's turmoil. ​